Cayugas close stores in wake of court ruling

By: Nathan Robson / The Citizen

Thursday, December 11, 2008 3:19 PM EST

Two Lake Side Trading stores owned by the Cayuga Nation have temporarily suspended operations pending a review of Tuesday's state supreme court decision that ruled the businesses could be investigated for felony tax evasion.
Dan French, an attorney for the Cayuga Nation, said the stores stopped all operations on Wednesday after he talked with the nation's leadership. The nation does not charge taxes on any purchases made at the store.

"The Cayuga Nation has always abided by the law, and the law seems to be in flux right now," French said. "Until there is more clarity we will temporarily suspend business."

In a written decision, state Supreme Court Judge Kenneth Fisher rejected the nation's lawsuit against the district attorneys' and sheriffs' offices in Seneca and Cayuga counties.

The nation claimed law enforcement illegally raided and searched their businesses in Seneca Falls and Union Springs on Nov. 25 because they were located on a reservation owned by a sovereign nation.

The tribe, along with other Indian nations in New York, have claimed they are exempt from collecting sales and excise taxes on their property because their businesses are protected by their sovereign nation status.

Fisher said the tribe, while recognized as a sovereign nation, did not have a recognized reservation according to New York state's tax laws. He also said that an injunction on a part of the tax law only prevented the use of a coupon system to exempt American Indians from paying tax, and did not excuse the tribe from collecting taxes on transactions made by non-Indians.

Fisher cited the decisions of several U.S. and state Supreme Court rulings involving the Oneida and Cayuga nations as the basis for his decision.

French said the nation will appeal Fisher's ruling.

Between the two stores, French said more than 30 employees were out of work, and that the nation will be losing a key source of income for its social programs.

"I am sure this will result in a hardship for the nation's programs," French said. "The revenue wholly supported their health care, roads, homes and employment."

Cayuga County Sheriff David Gould said the stores were allowed to sell taxed cigarettes and that there was no investigation into the sale of untaxed gas at either location.

"If they closed, it was not because we shut them down or told them they had to," Gould said. "We have maintained that they can sell anything at there stores as long as they are taxed."

But French said the nation had no intention of collecting excise or sales tax.

"The Cayuga Nation is a sovereign nation that owns these stores within their reservation," French said. "No nation, including the Cayuga Nation has ever collected or administered sales tax, and no nation has ever been required to do so."

The Citizens' Say

Post your comment - click here

There are 7 comment(s)

brew1234 wrote on Dec 12, 2008 12:28 AM:

" When someone opens a business that employs people we give them tax breaks to locate and open but when these guys open a business and provide jobs with no tax breaks we shut them down for not colecting taxes? It seems this could have been done differently with some compromise. "

colin1101 wrote on Dec 11, 2008 10:14 PM:

" ahhh but go to nedrow and you are not native american and you pay no tax for smokes. what is good for the goose is good for the gander "

Irene8585 wrote on Dec 11, 2008 9:49 PM:

" Just out of curiosity, how much tax money is the state going to lose from these working employees? And on top of that, how much are they going to lose when these employees are forced to live off the government? This is all about the government's greed...but I don't think they thought it through. "

james_13021 wrote on Dec 11, 2008 6:24 PM:

" Hooray!!!

Now maybe the gas station that burn down the road on Route 90 will finally rebuild. The owner had complained for years about how the Indians were undercutting their proffits for years. They refused to rebuild becuase they couldn't compete with them charging so little for gas and smokes.

Good riddance!!! "

rocky-g wrote on Dec 11, 2008 4:39 PM:

" Don't any of you know the great motto of our judicial system.EVERY ONE IS GUILTY OF WHATEVER THEY ARE ACCUSED OF UNTIL THEY ARE PROVEN INNOCENT.When was it proven that these stores were not on land claimed in the CAYUGA INDIAN NATION LAND CLAIM. "

trooper2b wrote on Dec 11, 2008 3:47 PM:

" You cant blame the officers for doing their job. the Indians closed the stores NOT the government! maybe people should be aware of both sides of the arguments before they comment. The Indians have no sovereign nation status in new york state as it was denied (referring to the Cayugas). The Indians should make sure they know the laws and know that they have no sovereign nation. Its not fair to the police or government when they are attacked by the citizens for doing their jobs!!!! What ever happened to the entire community policing concept and to researching a topic before you comment after reading what the twisted press has to say. "

Citizen editors wrote on Dec 11, 2008 3:34 PM:

" We mistakenly deleted this story while doing another update, and lost comments that had been posted as a result. Here are the comments that were submitted. We apologize for the mistake:



djp2157 on 12/11/2008 02:17:26 said:

"As a relative of an employee of Lakeside Trading, I feel the need to express my opinion. Lakeside Trading was and is very good to their employees, unlike alot of other employees in the counties of Seneca and Cayuga. Now I guess they'll have to stand in the unemployment and welfare lines until those benefits run out also. May you employees of Lakeside Trading have a blessed holiday, you'll all be in my thoughts and prayers."

cooldad on 12/11/2008 01:29:25 said:

"What Next IN THIS COUNTRY ???? This is a JOKE and A HALF. Impeach him as Governor and then procecute him. This is UNBELIVEABLE !!!"

Marsha on 12/11/2008 01:24:37 said:

"I feel for the employees who lost long standing jobs, probably people without great resumes."

nature lover on 12/11/2008 01:10:33 said:

"If u two posters had a clue u would know that the two Lakeside convenience stores are NOT repeat NOT on reservation land. Therefore they must charge tax. Now if they were on reservation land, it w/b for Indians only to get goods w/o paying taxes, non indian would be forced to pay tax. So no matter how u slice it, they are in violation. Besides, I have to laugh because where i buy gas it is ALOT of taxes added on and when u drive by Lakeside its like what 4 cents cheaper? What a rip off. Reservation = mask of freeloaders."

cooldad on 12/11/2008 01:08:29 said:

"KEEP MESSING AROUND WITH THE INDIANS , ESPECIALLY THE ONIEDA`S AND THE TURNING STONE WILL SHUT DOWN. THEN YOU`LL SEE HOW MANY PEOPLE WILL BE OUT OF WORK.THEY TRIED MESSING WITH THE ONONDAGAS A FEW YEARS AGO AND IT DIDN`T WORK.HEY, LEAVE THE INDIANS ALONE !!!"

dan w on 12/11/2008 12:56:49 said:

"The revenue wholly supported their health care, roads, homes and employment. This statement is quite the streach of the facts. Since I never stepped foot in any of the stores. I can't speak about employment. Health care is taken care of by the federal goverment. Roads what roads thats a joke right? Homes yeah buying up all the land to try to put in trust. Its time they joined the other 4 stores they put out of business."

bigal on 12/11/2008 12:53:20 said:

"The county has no right to step into an area that federal and state agencys are avoiding. Leave the Indians Alone!"

halfcent on 12/11/2008 12:44:30 said:

"typical of our great county,put more people out of work." "

REGISTRATION IS FREE.
Registered users sign in here:
*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 
Unregistered users can register here:

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

First Name:
Last Name:
Company:
Home Phone:
Business Phone:
Address:
City:
State:
Zip Code:
 
E-Citizen
E-Edition
Wheels Etc.
Find a vehicle
Hot Jobs
Find a Job
Homes Etc.
Find a Home
TV Week
Find a program
Search Classifieds
Find, Buy
Place a Classified Ad
Sell
Skaneateles Journal
The Journal
New! Best Bridal
Here comes the bride. . .
Liven Up the Holidays
Fa-la-la-la-la-la-la-laaaaaa
Logo HereNew! Off the Menu
Good Eatin'!
Newspaper Ads
See it again
CNY Boats Etc.
Achors aweigh!
Sections
Special Sections

Where to next?

Top Jobs

The Citizen Copyright ©2009
A division of Lee Publications, Inc.
25 Dill Street
Auburn, NY 13021

Contact Us

Add to My Yahoo!