Parade of trucks draws big crowd

By Christopher Caskey / The Citizen

Friday, November 28, 2008 11:44 PM EST

SKANEATELES - Hundreds of people lined Genesee Street in the village of Skaneateles early Friday afternoon to watch a parade. Some of them held signs, and some of them waved American flags. Many of them just stood on the sidewalk and gazed west, waiting to catch the first glimpse of the caravan.
Sam Tenney / The Citizen
Truck supporters line the corner of Genesee and Jordan streets in Skaneateles as a convoy of trucks passes through the village Friday afternoon. Truckers organized the convoy in protest of proposed regulations barring trucks from rural routes and a strict truck enforcement policy in Skaneateles.
But this wasn't a holiday parade coming down the village's main road. And it wasn't a new attraction added to the village's annual Dickens Christmas festival, which opened Friday.

The crowds descended upon Skaneateles to watch a parade of trucks rumble and honk along Route 20. The caravan was organized as a statement of protest against a proposed set of state regulations that would keep truckers from using certain rural, upstate routes as shortcuts.

Approximately 150 to 200 tractor trailers and diesel trucks drove in line from Waterloo through Skaneateles as part of the rally. The first trucks started rolling through the village at 12:45 p.m., and the parade lasted approximately 30 minutes.

The protest was staged on the same day as the kickoff for the Dickens Christmas, a village-wide festival that lasts through the holidays and is a popular event for both locals and out-of-towners.

Many of the spectators lining the street came in support of truckers, raising signs of encouragement and cheering as the drivers slowly ambled through town, one after another.

“It was a great sight to see when we came into the town,” Vincent Gramuglia, who has claimed to be one of the organizers, said after the rally. “I think it was a great success.”

Gramuglia is part of the Mohawk Valley Chapter of Truckers and Citizens United, the organization that staged the event. According to the group, the point of the rally was to protest regulations proposed by Governor David Paterson and the Department of Transportation to keep heavy trucks off of many rural roads.

The convoy proceeded along Route 20 for much of the way, though Route 20 is not restricted by the regulations. But many of the organizers have pointed to the village of Skaneateles as a symbol of anti-trucker sentiment.

Gramuglia clarified Friday that the organization does not have anything against the people of Skaneateles. It's the “small group of people” who are trying to dictate what goes on in the village, he said.

That “small group” is the Upstate New York Safety Coalition Task Force, a collection of regional residents and officials who rallied for the regulations. The coalition has contended that the trucks lessen the quality of life, wear down the region's infrastructure and create environmental hazards.

But truckers like Gramuglia say they are being unfairly targeted and that they have a right to use the public roads. The regulations would financially hurt the trucking industry, and that economic pain would pass onto consumers, Gramuglia said.

“We would like to try and sit down at a round table and and discuss this situation before it gets more out of hand,” said Gramuglia, who added that industry representatives are meeting with state officials next week in Albany to discuss the proposal.

David Card, of Skaneateles, also participated in the convoy. An owner of a trucking company himself, Card said it's time that people stop trying to take rights away from others.

People talk about keeping trucks on the Thruway, Card said. But if that happens, higher fuel costs and tolls will be more local and non-local companies can handle, he said.

“If we lose this, what's next?” asked Card, who said he knew of at least 25 or 30 local truckers who participated Friday. “These roads are paid for by people like myself.”

Spectators come to show support, concerns

While the day's main spectacle was the afternoon caravan, the streets were crowded by late morning. Some people formed clusters on corners and along sidewalks to claim a spot for watching the demonstration. Some meandered in and out of shops.

At noon, a crowd formed around the Sherwood Inn as the Dickens characters announced the start of the festival and sang Christmas carols.

Erica Leubaner, of Marietta, stood with a group of about 10 friends and family members to support the truckers' cause. As dairy farmers, Leubaner said her family depends on trucking in the area. Any rules that affect the trucking industry negatively will affect her family business in the same way, she said

Leubaner added that the first day of the Dickens festival was the perfect time to hold a rally.

“Any time people want to make a statement, they have to capitalize on a time when there's going to be a captive audience,” she said.

Skaneateles resident Jim Lanning was also there to support the truckers. He stood on the side of Genesee Street carrying a “Welcome” sign.

A truck driver himself, Lanning said local officials have been “harassing” local truckers for some time. This is ironic, he continued, considering all of the local merchants get their goods through commercial trucking.

“I think we can all get along together in harmony if we try,” Lanning said.

Not all the spectators were against the tighter restrictions, though. Skaneateles residents. J.D. and Darlene Lawson both raised signs imploring truckers to keep off routes 41 and 41 A.

The Lawsons live on Route 41, they said, and the trucks often come speeding down the road without much regard for the residents.

“That's a county road, not a state highway,” J.D. Lawson said.

He also said it was “disrespectful” of the trucking organization to hold the rally on the first day of the Dickens festival.

Skaneateles resident Bob Werner stood next to the road to watch the trucks. Events like these don't happen in the village every day, he said.

However, Werner said he understands the issues raised by local residents over the safety and environmental effects from heavy truck use in the area.

“Sometimes (the trucks) will tip over, and that can be a major concern,” Werner said.

Very few incidents, local officials say

Despite the large crowds and dissenting viewpoints, the trucks came and went with very few incidents. After the convoy passed through Skaneateles Police Chief Lloyd Perkins said that multiple New York State Police and Onondaga County Sheriff's officials were present in and around the village.

The truckers have a right to use the roads and a right to protest, Perkins said. The elevated force, he continued, was present to maintain public safety.

“I think it was very smooth,” sad Perkins. “I know that 99.9 percent of these truckers are great people.”

However, law enforcement did intervene a bit before the convoy reached Skaneateles. According to the state police, troopers in Auburn arrested John Cardinell, 69, of Weedsport and charged him with disorderly conduct and obstructing governmental administration.

Cardinell was one of the truckers in the convoy, according to the state police, though no police officials were available Friday evening for further comment.

State police in Auburn also gave out three other tickets when drivers stopped their rigs in the driving lanes and held up traffic.

After the event, Skaneateles Mayor Bob Green described the rally as a “peaceful” demonstration. Green said he hoped the increased foot traffic benefited local merchants and gave the village's annual holiday festivities some added publicity.

“I hope they feel like they accomplished something,” said Green, who noted that he thinks the truckers' issues should be taken up with officials in Albany, not Skaneateles.

“I do think their focus could have been better utilized finding solutions instead of spending a day and using fuel for a demonstration.”

An active participant in the Upstate New York Safety Coalition Task Force, Green said he expects the group to continue their efforts to restrict heavy truck traffic on rural, upstate routes.

In fact, coalition members met with officials in Albany two weeks ago to discuss the regulations, he said.

“After today's display, I think the coalition will become larger and louder,” Green said.

Staff writer Christopher Caskey can be reached at 253-5311 ext. 282 or christopher.caskey@lee.net.

The Citizens' Say

Post your comment - click here

There are 11 comment(s)

ldf1022 wrote on Feb 4, 2009 10:34 PM:

" U people that think its cool to see some dumb truckers protest for their right to blow through small towns and very small state hwys. The little hwy I live off of is a bike route # 1. The road has a lot of blind spots as well. I have know problem with the plow, garbage or milk truck blowing through they are not going by all the time. But when U have seen what I have to live with these smelly loud truckers that rattle my windows when they cruise on by and pollute my air and don't allow me to live in a peaceful enviroment. Some people need to really wake up and smell the fumes and hear the noise I hear. Summer time is really a treat by me. I will pray this bill gets passed and will not rest intill it doe's! "

brew1234 wrote on Nov 29, 2008 1:42 PM:

" hadenoughofu, did you read the regulations that the Citizen posted? There is nothing there that bans trucks from picking up milk or delivering to farms, factories or stores. Please give informed opinions not just comments on rumors and falsehoods. Any trucker that takes back roads to save a few bucks on tolls is spending much more on wear and tear on his rig and wasted fuel making stops in every small town. These are facts. "

Biggguy wrote on Nov 29, 2008 11:48 AM:

" It seems that most of the problem is the garbage from NYC going to Seneca Meadows. Why can't the state determine that the garbage is hazerdous materials, and require the trucks to post placards identifing the cargo as such. Then the state or locality could post selected roads & streets where most people do not want these trucks passing through, and the cops could write tickets to the drivers.

Either that, or hire some senior citizens to drive 30 mph, with their left blinker on, to drive the roads the unwanted truckers frequent. "

nature lover wrote on Nov 29, 2008 11:13 AM:

" To make a point clear I was at the FL Mall, bell ringing outside. Yes it was a different view but it was Skaneateles that took the brunt of these non informed truck lovers.

Bottom line is this people, all rhetoric and side taking put down and read one sentence and soak it in:

The law is the law in the books now!!

I would imagine the commercial vehicle violation task forces are gonna keep up their excellent work. They will continue to pull trucks over. But as time passes, local haulers delivering goods like Weggies and Wallie world will be free to pass with no interuption. All will find the newly passed laws will actually target the trash haulers because it is a proven fact that they are ones that take the shortcuts for no reason but to save time and these are the trucks with the highest vehicle violations in safety.

Let the process take effect and I think ALL will be happy with the outcome. It is the law now so let our trusted law officials do what they are hired to do. "

Citizen editors wrote on Nov 29, 2008 10:25 AM:

" For additional information, here's the wording from the proposed regulation:

Section8000.13ReasonableAccessHighways
(a)Trucksareexcludedfromfollowinghighways:
(1) NYRoute 41betweenU.S. Route 11andUSRoute 20inCortlandandOnondaga
Counties;
(2) NYRoute 41AbetweenNYRoute 41andUSRoute 20inCortland, Cayuga, and
OnondagaCounties;
(3) NY Route 90 between U.S. Route 11 and US Route 20 in Cortland and Cayuga Counties;
(4) NY Route 38 between NY Route 90 and the southern Auburn City line in Cayuga
County;
(5) NY Route 79 between U.S. Route 11 and the eastern Ithaca City line in Broome, Tioga
and Tompkins Counties;
(6) NY Route 89 between the western Ithaca City line and US Route 20 in Tompkins and
Seneca Counties;
(7) NY Route 96 between the western Ithaca City line and NY Route 414 and between NY
Route 414 and US Route 20 in Tompkins and Seneca Counties.
(b) As an exemption from Section 8000.13 (a), trucks may utilize the excluded highways:
(1) if these highways constitute a reasonable alternative route as defined in Section 8000.11, or
(2) if use of one of these highways is necessary because it provides exclusive access to a
specific freight terminal, facility for food, fuel, service or rest, or site for the pickup or
delivery of merchandise or other property; or
(3) if, from a freight terminal described in paragraph (b)(2) of this Section, the excluded
highways provide the shortest trip to the truck’s next freight terminal destination or the
shortest trip to the network of Qualifying highways; or
(4) if use of the highway is necessary because highway closures, weather conditions, or other
factors render alternative routes inaccessible or unavailable for truck travel. "

kaffyo wrote on Nov 29, 2008 9:52 AM:

" i went to the truck rally let me tell ya it was amazing to see all the support for the truckers and their family's and if there was people putting down the truckers they were hard to see that's how many people were there to support at least 1000+ supporters.KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK TRUCKERS "

hadenough wrote on Nov 29, 2008 9:30 AM:

" brew1234
Again you make no sense, if trucks are banned from rural roads like 20,34,41 and 41a, how will the tanker trucks get to the farms.Like I said before you cant just ban certain trucks. "

Farmer's Gal wrote on Nov 29, 2008 7:23 AM:

" This description of the event does not match with the one given by naturelover, who witnessed it personally. Check the Two Cents page for a different view. "

john wrote on Nov 29, 2008 2:06 AM:

" I hear alot of talk about truck saftey...has anyone contacted the state about inplementing a program for new drivers to get information on how to properly operate a car around a truck..truck accidents? How many car accidents happen every day....how many people tailgate trucks..pull out in front of them, cut them off..think, thats 80,000 plus you just pulled in front off, not easy to stop. I wonder...does Skaneateles have any information to give to there student drivers about big trucks and how they operate? I do think Skaneateles got some publicity today but not the good kind...but you would have to have common sence to figure that one out. The bottom line is that Skaneateles has wined for years...the problem now is the governer has made it clear money talks. "

brew1234 wrote on Nov 29, 2008 1:38 AM:

" Is misinformation driving the thinking in this cause? No one is proposing banning dairy farms from getting transportation services by trucks. No one is blocking trucks from making deliveries to supermarkets. Why can the trucking industry people only make points with inaccurate information? If you can only defend your cause with lies and misrepresentation then you don't have a legitiment cause. "

Equality wrote on Nov 29, 2008 1:27 AM:

" Maybe someone should inform Mr. Lawson that State Route 41 is not a county road. That’s why it has state markers designating Rt. 41 well into Cortland County.

The county may plow it as contracted by the state, but it doesn't make it a county road. "

REGISTRATION IS FREE.
Registered users sign in here:
*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 
Unregistered users can register here:

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

First Name:
Last Name:
Company:
Home Phone:
Business Phone:
Address:
City:
State:
Zip Code:
 
E-Citizen
E-Edition
Wheels Etc.
Find a vehicle
Hot Jobs
Find a Job
Homes Etc.
Find a Home
TV Week
Find a program
Search Classifieds
Find, Buy
Place a Classified Ad
Sell
Skaneateles Journal
The Journal
New! Halloween Central
Boo!!
New! Best Bridal
Here comes the bride. . .
New! Election HQ
Here come the politicos
Liven Up the Holidays
Fa-la-la-la-la-la-la-laaaaaa
Logo HereNew! Off the Menu
Good Eatin'!
Newspaper Ads
See it again
CNY Boats Etc.
Achors aweigh!
Sections
Special Sections

Top Jobs

The Citizen Copyright ©2009
A division of Lee Publications, Inc.
25 Dill Street
Auburn, NY 13021

Contact Us

Add to My Yahoo!