Governor: Trucks to stay on highways

By Christopher Caskey / The Citizen

Tuesday, May 13, 2008 11:44 AM EDT

SKANEATELES - Truck drivers driving large tractor trailers to upstate landfills will soon have to think twice before leaving the main highway, Gov. David Paterson said Monday.
Sam Tenney / The Citizen
Gov. David Paterson speaks at Monday afternoon's press conference in Skaneateles announcing new restrictions on use of local roads by out-of-town truck drivers.
Paterson, U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer and a handful of state and local officials announced that the state Department of Transportation will develop a new policy to keep large, non-local trucks from traveling through towns in the Finger Lakes region.

The new regulations will be available for public view by the first week of June. Paterson said he expects them to be implemented this summer.

“We are trying to do this as quickly as possible,” Paterson said.

The announcement was made at a press conference on the lawn in front of the Sherwood Inn. The historic hotel is adjacent to Route 20, on which many tractor trailers loaded with garbage drive on their way to local landfills such as Seneca Meadows in Waterloo.

Paterson did not detail the specifics of the future policy, but he said the regulations would exclude local pick-up and delivery vehicles. The point will be to keep the large trash trucks on interstate highways, he said.

“The United States created the national interstate highway system specifically to transport freight all over this state and, of course, interstate commerce,” Paterson said. “Many of the roads in our towns are scenic. They are part of the great tourist attraction we have. We want to preserve it, and keep it that way.”

The state DOT will likely model its regulations after a similar policy recently enacted by New Jersey, Paterson said in a press release. That policy requires all large trucks to use a national network comprised almost entirely of interstate highways.

Truckers may only leave that network when seeking food, fuel, rest, repairs, or to reach a terminal by the direct route, which entails the shortest travel distance, according to the New Jersey Department of Transportation.

The new regulations in New York are a response to concerns over the fumes, noise and safety hazards created by the trucks as they drive along rural routes, Paterson said. Citizens have also raised environmental concerns over the possibility of a truck spilling its contents and contaminating the watershed, he said.

The Upstate New York Safety Coalition Task Force has been one of the citizen groups raising such concerns. The coalition of local residents and officials has met with state representatives in Albany numerous times in regards to the issue.

George Farenthold, vice president of the task force and an Aurora village trustee, said the trucks affect more than just quality of life. Four water mains have broken in Aurora over the last 20 months, Farenthold said.

Large tractor trailers routinely drive through Aurora on Route 90, he said.

“These overweight trucks are stressing the infrastructure,” Farenthold said after the press conference. “This is about the greater good and the best interest of the public.”

State Assemblymen Brian Kolb, Gary Finch, Will Barclay and state Senator John DeFrancisco also spoke. Numerous large, noisy trucks passed by on Route 20 during the press conference. However, the vast majority of the trucks were local, construction-related vehicles.

“Today, we don't have any of those garbage trucks. They heard that we're coming,” Schumer said.

Not everyone was pleased Monday after the announcement. Kendra Adams, president of the New York State Motor Truck Association, said the organization is “incredibly disappointed” to hear about the governor's plan.

Members of the motor truck association have been aware of the concerns over the trash trucks and have offered some solutions to officials, Adams said. The truckers are taking the rural routes for basic economic reasons, such as saving fuel and avoiding tolls. They will avoid the routes if they have a financial incentive to do so, she said.

And while Monday's conference focused on large trucks hauling trash, state transportation regulations would be a financial hit to truckers throughout the state, Adams added.

“To just restrict (their travel) to interstate highways puts the financial burden on them,” Adams said of the truckers. “It will only serve to continue to increase the cost of goods in this state.”

Seneca Meadows District Manager Don Gentilcore said Monday that most of his customers are actually based in upstate locations. Regulations keeping trucks on the interstate highways will definitely have an impact on the upstate economy, including both the truck companies and the taxpayers, he said.

Seneca Meadows has advocated for a comprehensive regional study on the issue, Gentilcore said. That way, lawmakers can hear from all the parties affected by new policies.

“Sometimes we are a little too quick to make decisions,” he said. “More information needs to be gathered.”

But Skaneateles Village Mayor Robert Green said the community has been fighting for decades to keep the hundreds of trash trucks from taking the rural routes in Central New York every day.

“We're very grateful as a community,” Green said after the press conference. “This is a great day for local communities in the Finger Lakes.”

Staff writer Christopher Caskey can be reached at 253-5311 ext. 282 or christopher.caskey@lee.net.

See the video

For video coverage from Monday's press conference, go to auburnpub.com

The Citizens' Say

There are 10 comment(s)

nature lover wrote on May 14, 2008 12:30 PM:

" Definantely GML, I Thank them wholeheartedly...the whole idea of the thruway becoming free, was a past politicians idea and most likely made them look great for that period of time. But honestly, did anyone really think the thruway was ever really not going to be a toll road? The reason the thruway is mismanaged now is because for some tarded reason they added the canal system to it and that is sucking it dry. Crap on those downstate trash haulers anyway. Why does everyone defend them? "

GiveMeLiberty wrote on May 14, 2008 11:52 AM:

" Eliminating the tolls on the Thruway altogether is not an option?

What we are witnessing here is the breakdown of the republic we were entrusted to protect.

The Thruway was supposed to become free after the tolls paid for its construction, a goal which was reached decades ago.

If we were to take a poll of NY residents, how many would be in favor of a free Thruway? If you believe as I believe that the majority of people would like to see the Thruway free, then ask yourself why it is not free. Are not the people supposed to be the rulers of the government?

Further troubling to me is the fact that our governor feels he can merely mandate anything he wishes and it will be done. Are we not supposed to author a bill, and have it passed into law if we want trucks off of our streets? Where is the consent of the governed in this situation? Should we pass all laws merely by decree of any politician whose party needs votes in a particular region?

Equally troubling to me are the people in this once great state whose default response to something they don't like is to beg our masters to exact their ill-gotten power upon our enemies. You didn't fight to take back your right to a free Highway system that you have paid for many times over with your ever-increasing tolls. Instead, you bowed to the pressure of the government that is SUPPOSED to be your servant. You allowed the tolls to continue to repel big trucks off the Thruway, and instead decided that if you were too meek to demand free passage for yourself AND the trucks, then you would humbly request that the same heavy-handed government who CREATED the situation in the first place merely force the trucks to use the toll road instead.
And the government smiled, knowing that it could hide behind your support when it forced the trucks to use the toll road. You helped perpetuate the problem by giving them an excuse to generate more money on the toll road. . . and you then thank them for it. "

dgfenn wrote on May 14, 2008 11:15 AM:

" Sen. Schumer, Gov. Paterson, SA Finch : Utilize the railroad system(s) and eliminate garbage trucks all together. "

nature lover wrote on May 14, 2008 10:15 AM:

" To inform further there already is a task force w/i our city police system...their nickname I cant type here. This great unit should be funded more because when they do stop trucks the fines are astronomical as these downstate trash haulers dont give one hoot for "laws" - they are overloaded and the trucks are in disrepair. So your idea to limit once per day on North St. is lame. They are going to Seneca Meadows not our landfill. And trains? NYC is already using trains to dump in the water there, the trash being hauled up here is the excess. They can use 81 in addition to the thruway and its a moot point that the thruway still charges travel fees. "

nature lover wrote on May 14, 2008 9:34 AM:

" mrbillb: do trash trucks go by your house that sits on a residential street? no? then shut up!! "

brew1234 wrote on May 14, 2008 12:30 AM:

" This governor looks like a man of action. It seems to be a good move. Does NY state give a discount for EZ Pass usage? The truckers could use EZ Pass and not have to stop and start at toll booths. This would save a few bucks for fuel and time. More if they get an EZ Pass discount. I mention this because New Hampshire gives 25% discounts on EZ Pass. They figure the clearing up of bottlenecks at the tolls and decreased manpower for toll takers makes it worthwhile. The truckers need a break on fuel taxes to price their fuel on par with auto fuel. The state should reduce the fuel tax about 40 to 50 cents gal. to put it approx the price of gasoline. "

mrbillb wrote on May 13, 2008 9:36 PM:

" Well,just for the record where does the trash go that the village of Skaneateles produces??I feel a completely different approach to the trash trucking possibly could have been worked out.After all these trucks are required to pay a NYS road use tax,and also who can begrudge them of saving precious diesel fuel at a price of plus $4 a gallon. I believe that if number one the laws were enforced IE speeding,covered loads,and open doors when empty,that most likely truckers would find the Thruway more attractive.But now on to possible solutions,allow the truckers to use a designated North/South road only one day per week,a different road each day,only operate on that road between the hours of 7AM-7PM..We are worried about a truck spilling trash in the lakes,What is going to happen when the trash starts coming to Finger Lakes by rail???I certainly don't feel comfortable with their track record of derailments,that could be a calamity,seeing as the tracks follow the Barge/Erie Canal.While on the subject,not us not forget that these truckers will be forced to the Thruway,a road that decades ago was suppossed to be paid off and free.It looks as if the Thruway ,what with just raising the rates are in for another windfall if the truckers are going to be made to use that route only. "

marsha wrote on May 13, 2008 1:00 PM:

" good idea, to bad it was not in effect in 1982 when we lived on route 90 in Union Springs. "

Farmer's Gal wrote on May 13, 2008 12:38 PM:

" Thanks, Missy and naturelover, for the useful info on the truck routes up 38A. I looked on Mapquest and see that the place which interests me is on "N Main" which turns into "Rockefeller," which turns into 38A and is NOT 38A as far south as Moravia.

I had heard many times that "Rockefeller Rd is 38A" -- and so it is, at the north end, but 38A swings away east at Owasco, as you say. I've lived West of Owasco Lake for the past 25+ years and was a bit fuzzy on geography East of Owasco.

For those interested in a whole day's worth of discussion attached to the preliminary version of this article, see: http://www.auburnpub.com/articles/2008/05/12/latest_news/2latestnews.txt "

Unknown... wrote on May 13, 2008 12:20 PM:

" I knew it would be a matter of time before the people in Skaneateles would be whining about trucks going through there!! I hope they apply it to Auburn, too. "

REGISTRATION IS FREE.
Registered users sign in here:
*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 
Unregistered users can register here:

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

First Name:
Last Name:
Company:
Home Phone:
Business Phone:
Address:
City:
State:
Zip Code:
 

What to Watch

Multimedia

Slideshows

Slideshows

Local Video

Citizen Videos

Your Photos

Photos

Top Homes

The position is required for AdSys ads.

Top Jobs

The Citizen Copyright ©2008
A division of Lee Publications, Inc.
25 Dill Street
Auburn, NY 13021

Contact Us

Add to My Yahoo!