Adoptees will have the same right to the birth records and early health histories as every other person has always had, under legislation pending in the state Senate and Assembly. Currently, eight other states offer this right and several others are considering it. Adoption records in Kansas and Alaska have never been sealed.
New York began sealing adoption records in the mid-1930s to protect adoptive parents from possible interference from biological parents. Contrary to popular assumption, however, there has never been a legal guarantee of secrecy offered to birth parents who have given up their children for adoption.
Since the 1930s, social perceptions and medical research have evolved to the point where most professionals in the field of adoption agree that open adoption and background information is to the benefit of all concerned. For example, one of the first things a doctor needs to know is a patient's medical and psychiatric history. Currently, that potentially life-saving information is obtainable only by court order and at considerable cost to the individual. Unfortunately, it is usually not sought because of those deterrents, to a patient's serious disadvantage.
Other adoptees seeking their birth records believe that the matter is one of basic human rights, including the right to know one's heritage, something that is taken for granted by everyone else. Such denial of access consigns adoptees to second-class citizen status.
The proposed adoptee rights legislation strikes a balance between an adopted person's right to know and the confidentiality concerns of biological parents.
With the political fray in Albany this year, these bills need the attention and support of your elected officials. Please contact your state senator urging support of bill S235 and your assemblyman of bill A2277.
Joyce Bahr
Gracie Station
Bahr is president of New York Statewide Adoption Reform, Unsealedinitiative@nyc.rr.com
Since the 1930s, social perceptions and medical research have evolved to the point where most professionals in the field of adoption agree that open adoption and background information is to the benefit of all concerned. For example, one of the first things a doctor needs to know is a patient's medical and psychiatric history. Currently, that potentially life-saving information is obtainable only by court order and at considerable cost to the individual. Unfortunately, it is usually not sought because of those deterrents, to a patient's serious disadvantage.
Other adoptees seeking their birth records believe that the matter is one of basic human rights, including the right to know one's heritage, something that is taken for granted by everyone else. Such denial of access consigns adoptees to second-class citizen status.
The proposed adoptee rights legislation strikes a balance between an adopted person's right to know and the confidentiality concerns of biological parents.
With the political fray in Albany this year, these bills need the attention and support of your elected officials. Please contact your state senator urging support of bill S235 and your assemblyman of bill A2277.
Joyce Bahr
Gracie Station
Bahr is president of New York Statewide Adoption Reform, Unsealedinitiative@nyc.rr.com
The Citizens' Say
There are 5 comment(s)
msusiecu wrote on Apr 2, 2008 3:01 PM:
It is a myth that we wanted confidentuality in fact, in my 18 yrs of being involved in 26 different adoption related groups I have concluded that about 97% of parents hope to someday know their child is ok. It is unbelievable to me that the inhumane laws in most states, have not been changed already. "
lminisce wrote on Apr 2, 2008 2:06 PM:
BorninBing wrote on Apr 1, 2008 9:40 PM:
Natalie14612 wrote on Apr 1, 2008 8:12 AM:
Many thanks to Joyce Bahr for all her hard work. Thanks, too, to MY state legislators, Senator Joseph Robach and Assembly member David Koon of the Rochester area, for sponsoring this bill. "
Gaye Sherman wrote on Mar 30, 2008 9:31 AM: