Dentist nears planning board approval for medical complex on McIntosh Drive

by Jessica Soule / The Citizen

Wednesday, March 7, 2007 9:37 AM EST

AUBURN - After 22 years at someone else's practice, Auburn dentist David Nagle is ready to start his own.
With the Auburn Planning Board's nod, he's one step closer to his dream.

The board gave preliminary approval Tuesday for the concept of a three-structure medical complex on McIntosh Drive.

Nagle aims to occupy a 4,200 square-foot building himself, and find other medical practitioners for the two remaining separate office buildings, estimated for 4,000 square feet and 6,000 square feet.

The six-person board required Nagle to present plans for his building, which likely will stand first, and then the other two, when he's ready to build them. Nagle's Syracuse architect Jim Hagan plans to begin construction on the first office this spring, depending on the board's final approval.

While no member of the public attended the open hearing, the board received two letters stating concerns about the project.

Philip Walotsky, owner of Murray Hill Apartments, wrote one letter. Also, 15 people, - most , if not all, of them believed to be residents of the apartment complex - signed another correspondence voicing objections to “a project of this magnitude.”

The residents pointed to the likely increase in traffic off of Grant Avenue, causing bottlenecks and potential danger to pedestrians. City planner Stephen Selvek noted the Auburn Police Department representative approved of the traffic flow and driveway layout and the Auburn Fire Department suggested only one minor change to the driveways to accommodate its equipment.

The letters also brought up questions about the property's location, which borders commercial and residential plots. The final plan will include specific buffers required to help ease the transition between the commercial setting and the nearby neighborhood, Selvek added.

“This area is zoned commercial. I could have a used car lot if I wanted, legitimately, without a problem,” Nagle said. Chuckling, he assured the board he simply wanted a dental practice.

The Zoning Board of Appeals granted Nagle a use variance in October 2006. Although the land already bears a commercial label, the Auburn dentist required a zoning variance to allow professional office buildings on the land.

Nagle owns nearly 13 acres north of the Auburn Plaza, but the majority of the property lies in a designated flood plain. The project will take up the two acres not in the flood path.

Staff writer Jessica Soule can be reached at 253-5311, ext 267 or

jessica.soule@lee.net

The Citizens' Say

There are 23 comment(s)

facts wrote on Mar 11, 2007 5:06 PM:

" let's further correct the facts. Dr Nangle and ONLY 1 of the brothers actually owned the business. "

E wrote on Mar 10, 2007 8:02 PM:

" I think the best denists in Auburn are the two Lesch brothers. They have a beautiful building on Genesee Street where patients have always felt comfortable and relaxed. Dr. Nangle worked WITH them not FOR them and partially owned the business for 22 years. Let's correct that point as well. "

BREAKDOWN OF FACTS wrote on Mar 9, 2007 3:00 PM:

" I have read both sides of this discussion and can't believe the comments. Those supporting the Dr.indicates that 1) He is a good Dentist 2) He could have moved 3)This will help the tax base 4)The people complaining don't pay taxes or are Senior citizens 5) McIntosh is really a Grant Avenue extension. Those against say 1) the land was not zoned for this and was changed for his special use (THIS IS A FACT) 2)Businesses are leaving the down town area and this could hurt the economy (Again this sounds very true) 3) This is a residential area (AGAIN A FACT) 4)The turn onto McIntosh is a busy one (FACT) and what will happen with another couple of hundred cars 5) There is plenty of available property for sale in Auburn that could have fit his needs (FACT) 6)The named complaintant in the article does own the bordering property and does pay taxes (FACT) I didn't have an opinion on this when originally written, however it doesn't appear that those supporting Dr. Nangle have backed him with any substance. Those against have raised REAL QUESTIONS. Why doesn't Dr. Nangle reach out and respond? "

WOW wrote on Mar 8, 2007 6:24 PM:

" how some people complain! Dr Nangle ( note the correct spelling) is probably the best dentist in Auburn. I ought to know, I travel 30 miles to go to him and he has done extensive first class work on me and my family. He is honest and hard working and responsive to emergency situations.His facility is top notch, even in a temporary location, and his equipment is state of the art. You can get a crown in one visit as it is made onsite. I think it is a great location and will only add to auburn's tax base and economy. His building, from what I hear, will be very classic. His staff is also the best! "

DON`T STOP WROTE wrote on Mar 7, 2007 11:49 PM:

" WHAT`S THE MATTER SENIOR? DOES MILLIE HAVE YOUR TONGUE? "

Amazed wrote on Mar 7, 2007 10:18 PM:

" It'a amazing how you people want to cry about everything. It is the man's property that he OWNS and if he wants to build on it, that is his right. If you don't like it, just move. You live in an apartment anyways so what do you care if there is one more business there? That's what Grant Ave. is - businesses. Deal with it or get out. "

Millie wrote on Mar 7, 2007 9:46 PM:

" senior, you say people are leaving Auburn. Yes they are, not because of the cold weather as much as the antiquated thinking. You say it is busy in that area. Why did you move there in the first place? It has been busy on Grant Avenue since the late 60s - get a grip and will the last one to leve Auburn please turn off the lights? hey Senior you wont be able to buy traditional light bulbs in a few years either oooo, hello the country is going halogen, or is that too much change for you too? "

Senior citizen wrote on Mar 7, 2007 7:51 PM:

" Millie-I realize you probably missed all 12 years of grammar and high school, but no where in my comments did I complain about living on a fixed income. My comments are very clear to anyone that can read....you don't live on Murray or McIntosh. The traffic is deplorable and a safety issue. The good Doctor claims to see 60 patients a day. This coupled with the 10 -12 other physicians that will be filling his "hardship" will create 700 to 800 additional cars on that street, The connector road will not alleviate this and a bad situation will become worse. WHERE DO YOU STATE ANY FACTS HOW THIS WILL MAKE THINGS BETTER? "

Millie wrote on Mar 7, 2007 6:37 PM:

" we are all SO SICK of you SENIORS and your penny pinching-I can't afford it whining. You all constantly harp on your fixed income, we know that there is savings, CDs, investments socked away. You are not fooling anyone least of all your kids with your crying poverty. Have you asked yourselves ever "Could I help my kids or grandkids with all this I am hoarding?" Of course not!! Well guess what, YOU ARE NOT GOING TO LIVE FOEREVER!!!! AND YOU CAN'T TAKE IT WITH YOU!! PLEASE STOP WHINING, go volunteer or exercize, something! "

Senior citizen wrote on Mar 7, 2007 5:13 PM:

" I was born and raised in Auburn and PROUD of it. Most of my family lives locally and they are raising their families here as well. My husband and I paid taxes for over 35 years and downsized since we were not able to maintain our home the way we once did. I attend town meetings and KNOW that about $1000 of each apartments rent is paid in taxes by our landlords to the town. That means Standart Woods is paying $350,000 and Murray Hill is paying $40,000 a year in taxes. Yes I don't pay taxes directly any more, but it is ignorant to attack us seniors, because we are the ones that made this town the town that it is. To tell me that this is going to benefit our town is probably the dumbest thing I have ever heard. More and more people are leaving the city. This WILL AFFECT US IN THE FUTURE. There are plenty of other locations for this type of complex.The property near Dunkin Donuts is an eyesore and is correctly zoned for a medical complex. How about the old McDonalds. Theres plenty of EMPTY locations that could be looked at. I am not against the good Doctor expanding, but feel there are plenty of other alternatives and they should be looked at. "

Millie wrote on Mar 7, 2007 4:49 PM:

" Hello renters: you do not pay property taxes, GO FOR IT DR. NANGLE!!! "

Don't Complain wrote on Mar 7, 2007 4:43 PM:

" In response to Mary-how do you know where Dr. Nangle's patients are from. In his old location, he was in a pratice with other dentists. No one knows how many of the "cars in the parking lot were his patients" as opposed to the other dentists. What does it matter. Quit gripping and let the man build his practice. Auburn is lucky to have such a skilled professional that is willing to stay. "

Tax payer wrote on Mar 7, 2007 4:26 PM:

" None of you people in Standart woods or Murray Hill apartments are paying taxes so shut up and keep quiet ! Build on Doc !! "

Lifetime in Auburn wrote on Mar 7, 2007 4:16 PM:

" In response to WAKING UP. Maybe you should smell the coffee also. It's not about new businesses. The Dr. is relocating and planning on taking a number of other professionals with him to his complex. The downtown will soon be just banks and lawyers. Your taxes will not decrease, they will increase since the downtown will become less and less desireable to conduct business. This is not a "NEW" business it is one that is relocating to a "RESIDENTIAL" neighborhood. "

Jerry wrote on Mar 7, 2007 3:12 PM:

" Come on Auburn----WAKE UP !!! I applaude Dr Nangle for wanting to keep his business in Auburn. It really is about time Auburn realized that this city needs more businesses and industries in our area---this would help to keep our taxes down and under control!!! If we keep going the way we are--no one will be able to aford their homes in Auburn(RE taxes will be way to high for the area--espaecially with no new businesses or industries.) Being born-raised & still living in Auburn,I feel this is a beautiful place to raise a family! So I want to wish Good Luck to Dr Nangle with his new business in Auburn!!!! "

old boy wrote on Mar 7, 2007 2:23 PM:

" if you were that concerned you should have attended the OPEN HEARING. just another writer looking to complain or start a conspiracy theory. good luck to the dentist !!! "

Old Boy wrote on Mar 7, 2007 1:20 PM:

" Guess the old boy club has spoken. How many people who approved this on the Zoning and Planning Boards are Dr. Nangles patients? Legally are they allowed to vote for something like this without stating they have a conflict. Guess it's "business as usual" with these boards. "

Think Green wrote on Mar 7, 2007 12:40 PM:

" I understand Dr. Nangle claimed hardship. Didn't realize things were so bad. His office always seems packed. When I was younger I had a lot of great times at the Hunter Brook site. It still is pretty, if you clean up the Brook. Why isn't the county getting state money and developing this as a walking path/ park area for the residents? We have too many empty buildings that the dentist could buy and move his office, especially downtown. THINK GREEN! "

Confused wrote on Mar 7, 2007 12:30 PM:

" Has anybody looked into how much additional traffic this is going to bring to McIntosh. That's a dangerous turn now. Whats going to happen with all the extra cars? "

Mary wrote on Mar 7, 2007 12:19 PM:

" Don't complain is misssing the point. First Dr. Nangle wouldn't move to Syracuse because his patients are in Auburn. Second No one questioned he is a good dentist. That area is residential in nature. This is a major commercial proposal. There is plenty of commercial property available in our area for sale why are the boards creating special zoning for a medical complex in a residential area. That is the question? "

Don't Complain wrote on Mar 7, 2007 12:09 PM:

" The name is Dr. David Nangle. I applaud Dr. Nangle for wanting to stay here and build. He is an excellent dentist and could have chosen to move his practice to another area such as Syracuse. Let's not complain and try to see the benefit this holds for the community. I wish you much success on your endeavor Dr. Nangle and staff. "

name wrote on Mar 7, 2007 11:27 AM:

" I think you mean Dr NANGLE "

Uncle! wrote on Mar 7, 2007 11:21 AM:

" I used to live in Standart Woods, if I were still there I would not want to see Dr. Nagle, or anyone, take on a project like this in this area as the area is just too busy. Are these new buildings really necessary, or is Dr, Nagle looking for a tax shelter? The last time I checked, there was still office space available at the new medical complex at the old Central High School, behind the Holiday Inn. Someone please say "uncle" and make the Grant Avenue development, building and traffic stop! "

REGISTRATION IS FREE.
Registered users sign in here:
*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 
Unregistered users can register here:

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

First Name:
Last Name:
Company:
Home Phone:
Business Phone:
Address:
City:
State:
Zip Code:
 

Multimedia

Slideshows

Slideshows

Local Video

Citizen Videos

Your Photos

Photos

Top Homes

The position is required for AdSys ads.

Top Jobs

The Citizen Copyright ©2008
A division of Lee Publications, Inc.
25 Dill Street
Auburn, NY 13021

Contact Us

Add to My Yahoo!