District addresses minorities' concerns

By Olivia Goldberg / The Citizen

Thursday, November 9, 2006 9:46 AM EST

AUBURN - Achievement, equity and perception.
Angela Kershner / The Citizen
Heidi Nightengale, director of Partnership for Results and member of Auburn's Diversity Task Force, acts as facilitator during the Auburn Enlarged City School District community meeting at the Booker T. Washington Community Center in Auburn Wednesday.
These were the three concepts Eloise Benjamin ultimately heard Wednesday evening in the Booker T. Washington Community Center gymnasium. It was there that she and roughly 100 people - representing Auburn schools, parents, students and stakeholders in the African-American community - gathered to discuss the racism a growing number of blacks have collectively identified and say they can no longer tolerate in the Auburn Enlarged City School District.

Benjamin, a youth pastor, is the mother of a 14-year-old boy who was suspended following a confrontation with another student at Auburn High School last week. Benjamin believed her son was singled out by administrators and ultimately suspended from school because of his Puerto Rican and black heritage. She believed this because the other student involved, who is white, was allowed to return to school.

“He's going to miss his classes,” Benjamin said of her son. “This is the time he needs to be in school.”

She wondered how many black and Puerto Rican students were graduating, “because if my kid is starting this way now, is he going to make it?”

Her question was central to the forum, part of a continued push in the partnership between school officials and concerned members of the black community to address the needs of troubled black students. Benjamin was not the only person there who perceived black students are unfairly treated, particularly at the high school and with disciplinary actions. Other parents, some Auburn High School graduates, stood up to discuss their own difficulties as students, or those of their siblings.

The forum had dual intents: to open more dialogue between community members and officials, and identify tangible priorities for officials, students, parents and other stakeholders to address.

Schools superintendent John Plume discussed an overview of the district's efforts over the last two years to address academic performance gaps between the general student population and black and African-American students.

Those gaps came out in comparison reports that showed fewer black students passed English language arts and math exams between grades three and eight than white students. Subsequent reports also showed the district progressed with certain student groups, including blacks, between 2004 and 2006.

During those years, more students met the graduation requirements for English and math. Still, Plume acknowledged the district has to do “a better job” of giving all students the opportunities they need to achieve academic success. He said he hoped the evening would offer the district assistance in reaching that goal.

“This is not like a flu shot. One night won't do it,” Plume said.

Dancer/choreographer Sean McLeod, of the New York Institute of Dance, attended. McLeod is a member of the district's diversity task force.

“We're going to come up with tangible things to walk away with, so teachers, parents, administrators and kids feel like they're being listened to,” he said.

To that end, all present were asked to look at 12 proposed suggestions for creating a more culturally receptive school environment and identify them in order of personal priority.

Among some of the most highly-ranked suggestions: hiring more African-American teachers; adding African-American counselors and advocates to meet mental health needs; mandating diversity training for all district employees and bringing more African-American role models into the schools.

BTW leaders will tally the proposals in order of importance and submit a report to the district.

Plume related the some of the difficulties Auburn schools face in hiring more black teachers, a concerted effort it has made over the last three years. Among the greatest challenges, he said, was locating minority candidates, then retaining them. He said two of the three black school teachers recently hired opted to move to larger urban areas.

“We've been largely unsuccessful being able to hire (black) classroom instructors,” Plume said.

Monique Wright-Williams, who heads BTW, was unfazed, and characterized the situation in the district as dire enough to merit immediate action.

“When you're telling a hungry person you're trying to get food, it's like, I don't care. Feed me or shut up.”

Meanwhile, it was all Eloise Benjamin could do to look at the imprint of Harriet Tubman on the district's letterhead - the paper notifying her of her son's disciplinary hearing - and not cry. Tubman is one of the historical figures most immediately associated with Auburn, and Benjamin wondered what the woman who embodies the spirit of the Underground Railroad would think of the obstacles that persist for black students today.

She asked, “Why are we still having all these problems?”

Staff writer Olivia Goldberg can be reached at 253-5311, ext. 235, or at olivia.goldberg@lee.net

The Citizens' Say

There are 31 comment(s)

monique wrote on Nov 11, 2006 12:23 AM:

" I think the comments all are excellent - they further identify the needs in the Auburn community. For anyone living in America to beleive that there is no racism is as ridiculous as stating that there's no White Beauty pageant - there is - it's called Miss America, Ms. America and every other pageant that has ever existed prior to the Black pageant. The reson for instituting a Black pageant is because there were seldom - if ever a Black person included in the others. And to fail to acknowledge that entertainment and special funds for white peole exists is simply ignorant - and that is why these things have to happen so that everyone can learn. There is far too much ignorance ruling the world. The studetns situation was not an example of being in trouble because he's black - his mother, and evryone else agree that he DID NOT start the fight - and in a world of zero tolerance it wouldn't matter who started it, but only once child was punished. In the absence of any true justification, what other conclusion is there? No, you don't need to have Black teachers who cannot teach - no more than you should have white teachers who cannot teach. Unfortunatley until white people are placed in an enviroment where NOTHING - absolutely NOTHING represents them in a positive light they will never understand. And shame on you for not trying to!!! "

The voice of truth wrote on Nov 10, 2006 10:14 PM:

" I say invite Bill Kuffs to your meetings. He seemed to enjoy the last social justice task force "

Jim Van Arsdale wrote on Nov 10, 2006 9:57 PM:

" I am a White parent, who attended the meeting on Wednesday night. As a life long resident of the Auburn area ,with two kids in our school district, I feel that this is a very important topic. I understand those who believe that race alone should not open doors, as I would not want to be discriminated for job because I am White. But for far to long in our history it alone closed doors. However, those of us in the racial majority must look to understand that we are benefactors of a White privilege. Think about it, growing up White people do not have to know anything about African American history. In contrast, African Americans are required to learn everything about White European history. If the reverse were true, I wonder what the drop out rate would be among White’s. The facts are we do live in a society that discriminates because of race. Until we face that fact, and decide to make honest steps to do what it takes the create mutual trust that is clearly not felt by all members of our community, nothing will change. The responsibility of our administration is to provide a quality education for all students, regardless of race. Clearly this should include having African American Educators in our schools. This is a great community, with enough people who care, I sure we will move forward in our collective thinking on this important issue. "

Discussion is needed wrote on Nov 10, 2006 7:57 PM:

" I think this these comments here are en excellent example of why more dialogue and examination are needed. Do I think everytime a person of color doesn't get a job, or is punished for something it is because of race?? Of course not, however, to say that people of color have the exact same opportunities as whites is ridiculous and shows the need for dialogue because white people clearly don't understand or recognize the racism and white priveledge that is alive and well. "

Jerry Morgan wrote on Nov 10, 2006 7:25 PM:

" I do not understand why we HAVE to go out and recruit black candidates to fill positions such as teachers, administrators,police officers, firemen, or what ever position is desired. All one has to do is advertise the position and hire the person most qualified. Period. If a person of color is the most qualified for the position advertised, then hire that person of colr. No matter what color that person is, black, red, white, chinese, or what ever. Hire them. To do anything else is racial profiling, something that is against the law "

ignorant .... wrote on Nov 10, 2006 6:55 PM:

" No..civil service tests are not racist..it's the fact that these departments already have racist tones to them, thus discouraging EDUCATED minorites from taking our exams...Hello - Syracuse, Rochester - they have a great # of minorities - we could have the same if our city wasn't so behind the times. Why would any educated minoity want to work here in this climate - I still say..Shame on Auburn "

Don, Killeen, Tx wrote on Nov 10, 2006 6:54 PM:

" I managed a kitchen for 17 years at our local military officer's club. The rule of thumb was simple,---I nevered asked who started the problem, who grab who, they were both fired. I always set the golden rule in place during their orientation which was 'everyone is a human being, and will be treated as such. If you raise your voice to one another, I give you one chance to work the situation out with the shift leader present, or you are both gone.' The true life situation exist here in this school decision---zero tolerence. The students are out for the rest of the year, or find yourself another school district in which the parents will have to pay since they will be from another school district area. This is a hard line, but race, sex, never becomes an issue---just zero tolerence was the deciding factor, period. "

tired of race card wrote on Nov 10, 2006 5:55 PM:

" Every black person has the same opportunities as white people. Its what they choose to do with it the opportunity that produces the outcome of their future. Its time the black community stopped using the race card for poor decisions that they make such as fighting and getting into trouble and then blaming a white person for them getting arrested and then they pull the race card issue. Get a life and make something of it!!! "

Reponse To Black American wrote on Nov 10, 2006 4:37 PM:

" Well put, thank you. Goes right back to the first comment on this post from Concerned "

to shame on us wrote on Nov 10, 2006 3:46 PM:

" police and fire are civil service exam jobs,are the tests for this job racist too? "

An Auburn Resident wrote on Nov 10, 2006 2:40 PM:

" Can't we all just get along!!!!!!!!!!!!! "

Black American wrote on Nov 10, 2006 2:28 PM:

" I am a African American member of this community and I would like to tell these parents if they took half as much time raising there children as complaining about the system, they would not be in trouble!! This is a joke and frankly an embarassment, your child broke the rules and now you feel he is treated unjust. The liberal schools actually take the time to listen to your nonsense which is even worse. GROW UP AND TAKE YOUR SPARE TIME TO TEACH YOUR CHILDREN RESPECT AND NOT TO ALWAYS BLAME OTHERS. "

Response to Angry White Female wrote on Nov 10, 2006 11:24 AM:

" EDUCATE YOURSELF AND YOU WON'T BE SO ANGRY. "

shameonus wrote on Nov 10, 2006 6:56 AM:

" Okay, our schools have one black teacher. Our Police Department has one black officer, our Fire dept has one black fire fighter....hmmmmmmmmmmmmm Mayor, I sense a pattern - LACK OF DIVERSITY! Please don't use the SAME excuse for all 3 depts.....If you believe in diversity - you will go out - and recruit employees who can perform their respective jobs!!! No need to scale back requirements - just make an effort to recruit - look outside the box for a change. "

angry white female wrote on Nov 9, 2006 11:45 PM:

" You know what I am really getting sick of? It seems like every time an african american person encounters a problem, they cry discrimination!! You know what, you are responsible for your own actions!! But you wanna talk discrimination?! How about BET( black entertainment television), United Negro Fund, the Miss African American Beauty Pagent, and there is another award ceremony on T.V for black americans that I can't think of the name. I think it is music awards!! So where is WET(White Entertainment Television,where is the United White Fund, and The Miss White Beauty Pageant?! Where are these? The truth is is if we white people had those things, then black people would cry discrimination, and I am really sick of it! It is rediculous going around blaming other people for your problems. We are all individuals and we all know right from wrong and we are all responsible for our own actions!! "

Truth Hurts wrote on Nov 9, 2006 6:50 PM:

" I get so sick and tried of the race card. They are singled out for a reason whether white or black. The truth in the matter is that some of these kids have made quite a name for themselves discipline wise. That's why they are singled. They are the ones normally making the trouble in a group. THE TRUTH HURTS. "

To Wa-C-Ya wrote on Nov 9, 2006 6:39 PM:

" I don't think anyone is suggesting that minority students be "let off" for bad behavior. I think it's being suggested that all students receive equal punishments, equal support, equal resources etc., regardless of their skin color. "

jackhardy wrote on Nov 9, 2006 6:32 PM:

" ...as a former minority teacher in Auburn , retired from 22 years of corporate communications at Colgate Palmolive , working very hard to finish working on my home in Auburn...I would like to work or help my hometown out with this initiative. my email address is: auburn_jack@yahoo.com let me hear from you. LET'S DO SOMETHING! "

Hey "Real Problem" wrote on Nov 9, 2006 5:37 PM:

" Maybe you should get real - racism doesn't exist in Auburn? Where do live - under a rock? Quick story for ya: last year a young man in 9th grade commented to me at a soccer game how upsetting it was to him at AHS that the black students were singled out for disciplinary action for infractions that white students got away with. The student who shared this with me was: white, honor roll, middle class. Funny how kids in school can recognize bias but adults like to pretend it doesn't exist. "

the real problem wrote on Nov 9, 2006 3:25 PM:

" the real problem is summed up in benjamins comment in the story 'how is he going to make it ?'THATS HER RESPONSIBILITY TO SEE HER CHILD DOES.tell him to stop fighting and crack down on the books.its the typical story,its someone else fault and responsibility,and lets blame racism instead of a students laziness or parents non-involvement "

Long Gone wrote on Nov 9, 2006 2:26 PM:

" My question is did this minority student start the fight? The problem today is their is no sense of work ethic and no respect in todays youth's. Parents working 90 hrs a week to get by. It is easier to blame the schools and race for the problems that start at home. "

So Called Racists wrote on Nov 9, 2006 1:22 PM:

" If teachers of color are are not available why entice them to come. We have qualified "non" color people here in Auburn who have chosen this profession to enter. Lets spend money to bring in others? That is discrimination at its finest!!! "

Wa-C-Ya wrote on Nov 9, 2006 1:20 PM:

" so if black & hispanic students break the rules, they should be let off because of their skin color.....now that makes sense "

Millie wrote on Nov 9, 2006 1:09 PM:

" One of the best best teachers I had in high school in the 60's at USCS was Latino, another was white, two I had in Massachusetts prior to that I'm sure now were gay, another one was an alcoholic and one probably had Alzheimers - they all had much to teach us and I remember them to this day. Look for the best qualified and dive off the PC diversity train head first. If they are good you will have diversity by good sound hiring practices. Don't overthink this ! "

a few thoughts wrote on Nov 9, 2006 12:33 PM:

" Hiring more African American teachers and counselors isn't necessarily the answer either. What many districts need are culturally sensitive teachers and administrators who are respectful of Black students for who they are. The more we push a dominant culture down the throats of kids the less they will succeed - a problem that isn't necessarily confined to minorities but also includes social class and gender. We must work to value all of our students for WHO they are without forcing conformity. For a great article on this topic, see Karolyn Tyson's "Notes from the Back of the Room: Problems and Paradoxes in the Schooling of Young Black Students." It can be found in the journal Sociology of Education 2003, Vol. 76. "

Dave wrote on Nov 9, 2006 12:32 PM:

" Mr. Plume start holding parents accountable and stop interrupting the education process with the age old race issue cards that often get played. Schools are not a secondary parenting resource, stop placing teachers in such a position along with the associated liabilities. Mr. Plume start leading or resign. Leadership can be a great example for kids, especially young adults. If you keep promoting the race agenda as an excuse for bad human behavior regardless of color, you will continue to afford young minority students with a life long excuse. "

Dave wrote on Nov 9, 2006 12:28 PM:

" Did Eloise weigh-in on the turf issue? If we voted the turf in - whould it be making a difference. Here is the real deal - it is not about black or white. It is about parenting. If there is zero accountability at home when your child's behavior is wrong at school regardless of circumstances we will continue to have these speeches and no results. Regardless of circumstances - it is unacceptable to strike another human being ... parenting 101. "

anonymous wrote on Nov 9, 2006 12:07 PM:

" I think that the district is talking about hiring quality teachers that are of color, not just based on race alone. Auburn is a small city with some diversity and the people just feel that the staff should reflect the community, some what. I don't anything wrong with that. I am also one for personal responsibility and having consequences dealt with appropriately. Unfortunely, this isn't the first time that it has been reported that Auburn has been a city known for dealing with racial tension. Which is ironic for a city that has a prison in the middle of town that has a frustratingly high percentage of people of color there due to various reasons, but on the other hand has a noticeable and important Black community with a long and great history. Hopefully, Auburn can turn the corner in terms of race relations. "

concerned wrote on Nov 9, 2006 11:14 AM:

" Lip service does nothing to improve our community. The school district need to find ways to recruit and RETAIN minority teachers - incentive packages can be developed, etc... Our children deserve better and parents are finally demanding better. "

citizen wrote on Nov 9, 2006 11:04 AM:

" how about hiring teachers based on education, not skin color!!!! hiring due to ethnic back grounds?? thats discrimination at it's fullest!black,white,hispanic,chinese,etc....hire teachers on their ability to do the job,not their skin tone! "

Concerned wrote on Nov 9, 2006 11:02 AM:

" What type of home life do these kids have? End of story... "

REGISTRATION IS FREE.
Registered users sign in here:
*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 
Unregistered users can register here:

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

First Name:
Last Name:
Company:
Home Phone:
Business Phone:
Address:
City:
State:
Zip Code:
 

Multimedia

Slideshows

Slideshows

Local Video

Citizen Videos

Your Photos

Photos

Top Homes

The position is required for AdSys ads.

Top Jobs

The Citizen Copyright ©2008
A division of Lee Publications, Inc.
25 Dill Street
Auburn, NY 13021

Contact Us